Flashing an LED, no matter how you do it, will never produce the end results of a xenon tube strobe
light. The rise and fall times of the xenon tube when it discharges is almost instantaneous, where as in an LED, the LED device
itself has a built-in capacitance, as well as a 'linger' from the reflector (which is what turns a blue LED into a white
colour), which prohibits any electronic design from matching the xenon tube. In addition, the circuitry for a xenon tube consumes
a fair bit of energy as the capacitors recycle for the next flash.
Although an LED occulting light (on more than off) does not match the sharp, attention getting characteristics of a strobing
xenon tube, the 'un-naturalness' of the light tends to attract attention. In addition, because it is on more than off, it is
far easier to get a visual bearing on the light from another vessel.
|